Cloudy Title in California: What Property Owners Need to Know

What is a Cloud on Title?

A "cloud on title" refers to an adverse claim or encumbrance that seems valid on the surface but is actually invalid or unenforceable.

It can result from issues like incorrect deeds, liens, or unresolved mortgages, which create uncertainty about property ownership.

This can discourage potential buyers, as the defect may remain even if the property is transferred.

Ultimately, a cloud on title can prevent someone from becoming the clear legal owner until the issue is resolved. In other words, a cloud on title can significantly deter potential buyers and prevent the transfer of clear legal ownership, as it creates uncertainty about who truly holds the rights to the property.

Examples of a Cloud on Title

For a title to be deemed unmarketable, any doubt must arise from a cloud on title—not just a restriction or defect affecting the property’s marketability (see Hocking v. Title Ins. & Trust Co., 1951).

If a third party claims ownership, this can create a cloud. A cloud on title can result from ownership disputes, record errors, or improperly handled transfers, such as a misspelled name on a deed. It may also arise from foreclosures, liens, unresolved construction permits, or easement violations.

If a property is foreclosed, it can create a cloud on the title. To resolve this, foreclosure proceedings may need to be reopened for a final judgment. Alternatively, if the original owner reaches an agreement to reclaim the property, the bank or entity must transfer the deed back to the original owner.

A cloud on title can be uncovered through a title search, which examines public records like deeds and tax liens.

How to Solve a Cloud on Title

A cloud on title can arise from unclear ownership due to past or current disputes or errors in record-keeping. Even something as minor as a misspelled name on a deed can result in an improperly recorded sale, leading to a cloud on the title and complicating ownership claims.

Remedies include filing a quiet title action, canceling an invalid document, or clearing debts or liens. A quiet title action differs from an action to remove a cloud on title, such as canceling an instrument or reformation (Civ. Code § 3412; Thompson v. Moore (1937) 8 Cal.2d 367, 372). The key distinction is that removing a cloud seeks to invalidate a specific document or instrument, requiring proof of its invalidity (Reiner v. Daniel (1989) 211 Cal.App.3d 682). A quiet title action, on the other hand, addresses broader ownership disputes without targeting a particular instrument, aiming to establish clear ownership free of competing claims.

Addressing open permits or resolving property use issues like removing structures on easements can also clear the title.

Proper probate and succession steps after an owner’s death can prevent future title complications and disputes.

Preventive Measures

Property owners can protect against a cloud on title by ensuring clear contracts with contractors and regularly reviewing title records.

Additionally, obtaining title insurance provides long-term protection, as it insures against defects in title, lien validity, and title searches (See Hocking; Lick Mill Creek Apartments v. Chicago Title Ins. Co. (1991) 231 Cal.App.3d 1654 (Lick Mill)). Title insurance covers the entire period of ownership, safeguarding owners and lenders if issues like liens are discovered.

However, it's crucial to be proactive, as properties with existing title defects may not qualify for title insurance.

Questions?

PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO REACH OUT TO US IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED HELP WITH REVIEWING A TITLE REPORT!